Broker client review template for renewals
Before a cyber renewal, the useful conversation with a client is not the application itself but the gap between what was answered last year and what this year's carrier is asking. This template holds that conversation on one row per cover line: the cover line, what was answered last year, the carrier question this year, the control it maps to, whether the evidence is current, the action to close the gap, the owner and the due date.
It is for a cyber broker running a pre-renewal meeting with a client. The carrier questions and the mapped controls come from the same documents the scanner reads; the cover line, the last-year answer, the evidence status, the action and the dates are a worked example, plainly labelled, and name no real client.
Download broker-client-review-template.csv (9 columns, a worked example of 12 rows).
The template, as the file reads
| client | cover_line | last_year_answer | this_year_carrier_question | mapped_control | evidence_status | action | owner | due_date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Funds transfer fraud (social engineering) | Yes | Does Named Insured require dual control when transferring funds in excess of $25,000? | ISO 27001:2022 A.5.3 Segregation of duties | Current | Confirm the second-approver rule still fits the new payment thresholds. | Finance Controller | 20 Nov |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Funds transfer fraud (social engineering) | Yes | Does the Applicant verify all vendor and supplier bank accounts by a direct call to the receiving bank, prior to accounts being established in the accounts payable system? | ISO 27001:2022 A.5.3 Segregation of duties | Under review | Attach a dated callback example for the last supplier change. | Risk and Compliance Lead | 20 Nov |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Cyber liability, first and third party | Yes | Multi-factor authentication in place for remote access by employees? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.5 Secure authentication | Current | Re-export the sign-in report showing the second factor on every remote path. | Head of Security | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Data restoration and business interruption | Partial | If you have a back-up of all of your critical data and systems, does that include an offline copy? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.13 Information backup | Expired | Log the offline copy rotation schedule and attach the latest restore test. | IT Operations Manager | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Data restoration | Yes | Are back-up restoration plans tested? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.13 Information backup | Expired | Run the quarterly restore test and attach the dated record. | IT Operations Manager | 5 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Cyber liability (social engineering) | Yes | Are Sender Policy Framework (SPF), Domain-based Message Authentication Reporting and Compliance (DMARC) or Domain Keys Identified Mail (DKIM) in place? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.23 Web filtering | Current | Attach the current SPF, DKIM and DMARC records for every sending domain. | Security Operations Lead | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Cyber liability, first and third party | Yes | Do you use Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) or a Next-Generation Antivirus (NGAV) software (e.g., CrowdStrike, Cylance, Carbon Black) to secure all system endpoints? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.7 Protection against malware | Current | Export the endpoint coverage report showing the tool on every device. | IT Operations Manager | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Data restoration and liability | Yes | Does the Applicant encrypt data stored on laptop computers and portable media? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.24 Use of cryptography | Current | Confirm every laptop and portable drive reports encrypted, with any exception named. | Head of Infrastructure | 25 Nov |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Cyber liability (social engineering) | Yes | Is multi-factor authentication (MFA) in place for web-based email logins? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.5 Secure authentication | Current | Attach the mailbox access report showing the second factor for web-based email. | Head of Security | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Cyber liability, first and third party | Yes | Do you require multi-factor authorization when your network is accessed remotely and/or when cloud resources are utilized? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.5 Secure authentication | Under review | Confirm the remote-access gateway requires the second factor on every path. | Head of Security | 1 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Data restoration and liability | Partial | Does the Applicant use multi-factor authentication for access to critical applications or databases (including those that contain personally identifiable information, private health information or payment card information? | ISO 27001:2022 A.8.5 Secure authentication | Missing | Name the databases without single sign-on and log the compensating control. | Head of Infrastructure | 5 Dec |
| Acme Managed Services (example) | Funds transfer fraud (social engineering) | Yes | When a vendor or supplier requests any change to its account details (including routing numbers and account numbers), do you confirm requested changes via an out-of-band authentication (a method other than the original means of request? | ISO 27001:2022 A.5.3 Segregation of duties | Current | Attach the callback procedure for any change to payee bank details. | Risk and Compliance Lead | 20 Nov |
Map a carrier application for free on the scanner. Two held applications to try it on: Coalition and Hiscox. The two worked answers: the funds-transfer verification question and what counts as MFA on an application. See what a saved submission keeps on the example of a saved submission.
Frequently asked
What is the review template for?
The pre-renewal conversation with a client, one row per cover line: what was answered last year, the carrier question this year, the control it maps to, the evidence status, the action, the owner and the due date.
Where do the carrier questions come from?
The same carrier documents the scanner reads, so the question and the mapped control match what the tool returns.
Is the example a real client?
No. The cover line, last-year answer, evidence status, action and dates are a worked example, plainly labelled.