SOC 2 CC6.3: Role-based access, least privilege and segregation of duties
Role-based access, least privilege and segregation of duties is asked by 34 of the 48 carrier applications, through 92 questions. The evidence to have on file is the bank or treasury platform dual-authorisation setup and the payment approval workflow, showing a second approver on a different device above the threshold. This page maps the control to the questions that reach it; it never says whether an applicant will be offered cover.
SOC 2 is read as criteria drawn from the 2017 Trust Services Criteria with the revised points of focus; a criterion is distinct from any suggested evidence, and a mapping to it does not establish that an applicant satisfies it. Every requirement here is our statement of its clause, cited to it, not the instrument verbatim.
Which carriers ask this control?
34 carrier applications reach this control: AIG, Aon, Arch Insurance, Aspen American Insurance Company, At-Bay, ATC Insurance Solutions Pty Ltd, AXIS Insurance, Beazley, BOXX Insurance, Capitol Indemnity Corporation (CapSpecialty), Chubb, CNA, Coalition, Corvus Insurance, Cowbell Cyber, Delta Insurance, Emergence Insurance Pty Ltd, Encore Fiduciary, Everest Insurance, Great American Insurance Group, The Hanover Insurance Group, The Hartford, Hiscox, Hiscox UK, The Hartford Steam Boiler Inspection and Insurance Company, Markel, Munich Re, Northbridge General Insurance Corporation, Ocean Underwriting, QBE, RLI, SURA Technology Risks Pty Ltd (SURA Cyber), Tokio Marine HCC, Trisura Guarantee Insurance Company. A carrier named here is a source document, never a customer or an endorsement.
What evidence should be on file for CC6.3?
Evidence guidance is our wording, not a statement of any standard and not binding on a carrier or an assessor.
- Role definitions and role-to-permission matrix
- Change-of-role tickets showing old access removed
- Privileged access list and review evidence
- Segregation of duties rules, for example developers cannot deploy to production unaided
- Role review results covering vendor and service accounts
Common gaps an assessor names
- Role changes add access without removing the old
- Broad administrator rights assigned by default
- Role definitions never reviewed
- Vendor or service accounts left out of role reviews
The one or two items a carrier would actually ask for
- the bank or treasury platform dual-authorisation setup and the payment approval workflow, showing a second approver on a different device above the threshold
- the callback or out-of-band verification procedure for a change to payee bank details, with a dated example
The application questions that reach CC6.3 (92)
Application question Does Named Insured require dual control when transferring funds in excess of $25,000?
Application question Cyber Crime (Only if applying for this coverage) Does the Applicant accept funds transfer information from clients over the telephone, email, text message or similar method of communication?
Application question Does the Applicant authenticate instructions by calling the customer at a predetermined phone number or require receipt of a customer identity code?
Application question Is approval by more than one person required to initiate a wire transfer?
Application question Does the Applicant verify all vendor and supplier bank accounts by a direct call to the receiving bank, prior to accounts being established in the accounts payable system?
Application question When a vendor or supplier requests any change to its account details (including routing numbers and account numbers), do you confirm requested changes via an out-of-band authentication (a method other than the original means of request?
Application question Before acting on a transfer, do you verify the request or account detail changes using a method other than the initial contact method (Example: the initial request is received by mail and verification is done by telephone?
Application question Is multifactor authentication (MFA) required to remotely connect to the network, all critical internet facing systems and privilege accounts?
Application question Are firewalls configured according to the principles of least privileges?
Application question Do you use 2-factor authentication to secure all domain or network administrator accounts?
Application question Does your organization send and/or receive wire transfers?
Application question If "Yes", does your wire transfer authorization process include the following: (1) A wire request documentation form?
Application question (2) A protocol for obtaining proper written authorization for wire transfers?
Application question Does the Applicant or its Managed Security Service Provider, if applicable, implement MFA for all administrator access?
Application question Does the Applicant employ a protocol to confirm transfer instructions including a call back, email or an alternative method of authenticating the instruction?
Application question Does the Applicant employ a protocol requiring more than one or next-level approval?
Application question Does the applicant have formal policies and procedures in place for secure fund transfers, such as senior management approval and obtaining verbal confirmation for any fund transfer requests?
Application question Prior to executing an electronic payment, does the applicant verify the validity of the funds transfer request or payment change request, with the requestor, via a separate means of communication prior to transferring funds or making payment changes?
Application question How are privileged accounts secured and managed?
Application question Prior to executing an electronic payment, do you verify the validity of the funds transfer request or payment change request, with the requestor, via a separate means of communication prior to transferring funds or making payment changes?
Application question Does the organization verify vendor/supplier bank accounts before adding to their accounts payable systems?
Application question Does the organization authenticate funds transfer requests (e.g. by calling a customer to verify the request at a predetermined phone number?
Application question Does the organization prevent unauthorized employees from initiating wire transfers?
Application question ve at SS bay Security Controls Does the Applicant have controls in place which require all fund and wire transfers over $25,000 to be authorized and verified by at least two employees prior to execution?
Application question a. Do the applicant's privileged users require more extensive training relating to phishing attacks?
Application question Does the applicant utilize a Privileged Access Management (PAM) solution?
Application question Does the applicant restrict Local Admin rights?
Application question Does the Applicant have written and documented procedures in place which are provided to Your Employees and which require Employees to authenticate all requested changes to vendor/supplier Or client/customer information (such as changes to bank accounts, routing numbers, contact information) with a phone call to an authorized representative of the vendor/supplier or client/customer at a pre-determined phone number on file?
Application question Exec/Employee directed request wire transfer without first validating the request with a call back to the requestor (inclusive of any owner) at a pre-determined work phone number or with a f ace to face confirmation?
Application question Does any applicant accept fund transfer requests from customers?
Application question If yes, is the funds transfer instruction validated by a method other than the original means of request?
Application question Do you physically and electronically limit access to sensitive information on a need –to-know basis and revoke access privileges upon a reduction in an individual's need to know?
Application question Do you physically and electronically limit access to sensitive information on a need-to-know basis and revoke access privileges upon a reduction in an individual's need to know?
Application question Do you use MFA to protect all local and remote access to privileged user accounts?
Application question Do you manage privileged accounts using privileged account management software (PAM) (e.g., CyberArk, BeyondTrust, etc.?
Application question If "Yes", complete the following: (1) Provide the name of your PAM software provider: (2) Is access protected by MFA?
Application question Do you actively monitor all administrator access for unusual behavior patterns?
Application question Do non-IT users have local administration rights on their laptop / desktop?
Application question Does your organization send and/or receive wire transfers?
Application question If "Yes", does your wire transfer authorization process include the following: (1) A wire request documentation form?
Application question (2) A protocol for obtaining proper written authorization for wire transfers?
Application question Payment Card Information (PCI) (e.g., credit card, debit card numbers or other financial account numbers?
Application question Do you restrict user access (employees, contractors etc.) on a business need-to-know & least-privilege basis?
Application question If Yes, which of the following accounts are enrolled into the PAM tool?
Application question Which of the following features are enabled on the PAM tool?
Application question Is logging and alerting configured for all privileged account activity?
Application question Are domain admin accounts limited to administrative functions only?
Application question Please provide the number of service accounts in the domain admin group?
Application question Do you configure service accounts using the principle of least privilege?
Application question Do you configure service accounts to deny interactive log-ins?
Application question Do you log the activity of service accounts that are able to override system or application controls (e.g. elevation Yes No of privileges, lateral movement etc.?
Application question Do you prohibit local admin rights on workstations for users?
Application question Do you ensure multi-factor authentication for any fund transfer?
Application question Do you have a process in place to confirm that any payment requests received by email are from a known source?
Application question Service accounts (accounts used by machines - not people - for running applications and other processes) have password lengths of at least 25 characters.
Application question What is the capability to deploy the highest priority patches outside the regular periodic patching processes? (for example, in the case of an in-the-wild exploitation of software for which an out-of-band patch is available)?
Application question There is an inventory of all service accounts (accounts used by machines - not people - for running applications and other processes
Application question Do you require dual control when transferring funds in excess of CAD 25,000? (Dual control refers to a process by which a transfer must be approved or confirmed by someone other than the initiator of the transfer.)
Application question Is multi-factor authentication (MFA) required for access to privileged user accounts?
Application question Are special privileges restricted to systems administration personnel with an approved need to have these privileges?
Application question Does the Applicant have a documented information security policy? (i) Are all employment positions clearly defined and employees assigned specific rights, privileges, and unique user ID passwords, which are reviewed and validated periodically?
Application question Does the Applicant receive, store, use or process financial account payment information, such as a credit card or debit account number?
Application question Do you physically and electronically limit access to sensitive information on a need to know basis and revoke access privileges upon a reduction in an individual's need to know?
Application question Does the Applicant require that requests to transfer of funds by wire, bank-to-bank, or other electronic funds transfer be accompanied by supporting documentation, such as an invoice?
Application question For such requests, does Applicant confirm the identity of the requestor and authenticity of payment instructions by telephone with the requestor? If yes, is the validity of the telephone number confirmed?
Application question Does the Applicant have transaction limits in place for such transfers?
Application question Does the Applicant have security procedures in place for electronic funds transfers? Are they automated?
Application question How often does Applicant transfer funds by any electronic funds transfer method?
Application question Do you have a written procedure whereby, all new (including changes to existing) payment details or contact details are confirmed by an alternative method to the original method used, before any payment is made?
Application question Do you require MFA (multi-factor authentication) for privileged accounts?
Application question Does your organisation send and / or receive wire / electronic transfers? If yes, is approval by more than one employee required to initiate the transfer of funds?
Application question Do you have a call back procedure to initiate payment to a new bank account or to change banking details for an existing bank account (in respect of internal staff and external vendor / supplier / client requests)?
Application question Do you have an approval threshold with your bank requiring a phone call from your bank to release funds on transfers over $25,000?
Application question Do privileged users have a separate administrative account in order to carry out specific administrative duties?
Application question Do you require two parties to sign off on any payment transfers greater than $2,000?
Application question Do you have policy in place to verify any changes to existing invoices, bank deposit information and contact information?
Application question Before processing a wire transfer of funds OR changing vendor account details, do you confirm the request by a secondary means of communication in order to verify the instructions are legitimate?
Application question Do you restrict employees' and external users' IT systems privileges and access to personal information on a business-need-to-know basis?
Application question Have you implemented a written policy requiring telephone confirmation (or by means other than email) with the payee or requestor, of the payment details before making payments (including wire and ACH transfers) in excess of $10,000?
Application question Have you implemented a written policy requiring multiple internal parties to confirm authorization before making payments (including wire and ACH transfers) in excess of $10,000?
Application question Does the Applicant verify new customer or supplier bank account information (including Name, Address and bank account details) prior to initiating any financial transaction with such supplier or customer?
Application question Does the Applicant have a call-back procedure to pre-agreed contact phone numbers, with customers or suppliers to authenticate any fund transfer instructions greater than $25,000 prior to transfer?
Application question Does the Applicant have a call-back procedure to pre-agreed contact phone numbers, with customers or suppliers to verify email change requested to supplier or customer bank account details (including account number, email address, contact information, bank routing number)?
Application question Do all fund transfers greater than $10,000 require at least two members of staff to authorise or a supervisor/manager to sign-off?
Application question Has the Applicant at any time during the past three (3) years had any incidents, claims or suits involving unauthorized access, intrusion, breach, compromise or misuse of the Applicant's network, including embezzlement, fraud, theft of proprietary information, theft or loss of laptops, denial of service, electronic vandalism or sabotage, computer virus or other incident?
Application question Are all new payees, and changes to existing payees' banking details, double authenticated with your bank?
Application question Do transfers > $10,000 require dual signature or supervisor / manager sign off?
Application question Are access controls employed using the principle of least privilege?
Application question Do you require multi-factor authentication for all access to privileged accounts, for both on premise and remote access?
Application question Is approval by more than one employee required to initiate a transfer of funds?
Application question Does your bank require two-factor authentication (e.g. call-back) for all electronic funds transfer requests?
Application question Do all third-party requests for changes to payment details (e.g. payee bank account details) go through a two-factor verification process?
Controls reached by the same questions
12.2 (CIS Controls v8), 12.4 (CIS Controls v8), 12.5 (CIS Controls v8), 5.2 (CIS Controls v8), 5.4 (CIS Controls v8), 6.3 (CIS Controls v8), 6.4 (CIS Controls v8), 6.5 (CIS Controls v8), 6.8 (CIS Controls v8), 7.3 (CIS Controls v8), 7.4 (CIS Controls v8), 7.7 (CIS Controls v8), 8.2 (CIS Controls v8), 9.5 (CIS Controls v8).
This control on the island, all controls on the controls index, the framework on the SOC 2 page, the carriers on sources. Map your own answers in the tool.